In the world of ultra-high-net-worth (UHNW) families, succession planning is a multifaceted process that can be laden with emotional and psychological intricacies. The Murdoch family’s legal battle over Rupert Murdoch’s succession hit the headlines and highlighted the profound emotional stakes involved when proper succession planning is neglected.
Unfortunately for the Murdoch family, this is being played out in public, not unlike HBO’s “Succession”, which is a good example of the consequences of how poor succession planning can be emotionally and psychologically devastating for an ultra-high-net-worth family.
Beyond a mere business strategy, succession planning is an intensely personal and emotional journey. Family heads often grapple with fears about the future, worried that unprepared or uninterested heirs might squander their legacy. These fears are well-founded.
Research¹ reveals that only around 30% of family businesses survive the transition to the second generation, and a staggering 90% do not reach the third generation.
The saying “rags to riches to rags in three generations” painfully resonates with many; even the super-rich and aristocrats are not immune. This often comes down to poor succession planning, and it is not necessarily best to hand the reins to the next generation or the next in line.
The recent Netflix series The Gentlemen is a great example of how, in some cases, the tradition of primogeniture is not always the best choice for preserving a family’s wealth and property.
How To Avoid The Psychological Toll Of Lack Of Succession Planning
The practical management of vast wealth usually involves lawyers, accountants, and family offices. Yet, the psychological toll of family disputes, often sparked by inadequate planning or manipulative tactics, can be devastating.
Janine McNab, COO of Harbor London, a leading mental health centre providing highly discreet care in central London to a global clientele, understands these complex psychological dynamics. She offers essential advice to families aiming to mitigate the harmful psychological effects of succession conflicts.
“We work with those affected by the psychological burdens of generational wealth and expectations that come with it. The individuals and families we support— whether successors or beneficiaries — face immense pressure to meet expectations and navigate complex family dynamics. When layered with existing emotional challenges, this can create significant psychological strain”, says Janine.
The Realities of Succession Planning
The psychological impact of succession planning (or lack thereof) cannot be overstated. Family heads may struggle with feelings of loss, failure, and a loss of control over their life’s work.
Potential successors face immense pressure to meet expectations, leading to stress, anxiety, and intra-family conflict. If left unaddressed, these dynamics can erode family cohesion and business stability.
“At Harbor London, we have seen first-hand the toll poor succession planning can have on families. The tension, rivalry, and unresolved emotional issues can lead to long-lasting damage, both to the business and family relationships. Addressing these psychological factors is crucial for a successful transition”.
“Though these individuals may appear to have a vast network, when you look closer, you will see that their circle is quite small, often comprised of those economically dependent on them. This constrains the support and understanding available to them, intensifying the pressures they face.
“The burden of expectations, coupled with a lack of meaningful connections beyond the family, can lead to deteriorating mental health, harmful behaviours, and substance misuse—factors that can further complicate the challenges of succession.”, Janine comments.
Recommendations:
To navigate these challenges, Harbor London offers the following recommendations:
- Start Early: Initiate the succession planning process well before it becomes an urgent need. Early planning allows for the identification and development of potential successors, ensuring they are properly prepared, and that other family or board members understand why they have not been chosen.
- Encourage Open Communication: Foster an environment where open and honest communication is encouraged. Transparent discussions about expectations, roles, and plans can help manage misunderstandings and align family members’ goals.
- Involve Professional Advisors: Engage with experienced succession planning advisors who can provide objective insights and facilitate difficult conversations. Their expertise can be invaluable in navigating the complexities of the process.
- Formalise the Plan: Ensure the succession plan is clearly documented and legally binding. A formalised plan provides a clear roadmap and reduces the potential for disputes.
- Address Emotional Needs: Recognise and address the emotional and psychological aspects of succession planning. Providing access to mental health professionals who specialise in working with UHNW families can help mitigate the emotional fallout and support family members through the transition.
The Role of Mental Health Experts
When succession planning falters, the emotional turmoil can be profound. Family heads may struggle with feelings of inadequacy and grief, while children may face increased stress and rivalry. Mental health professionals experienced in working with UHNW families play a critical role in these situations. At Harbor London, our team understands the unique psychological dynamics at play and provides targeted support to address these challenges.
“Succession planning is an intricate and emotionally charged process. By learning from high-profile examples and understanding the psychological dynamics involved, families can take proactive steps to avoid the pitfalls of poor planning.
“We work closely with families to create a supportive environment where open communication and emotional well-being are prioritised. By addressing the psychological underpinnings of succession planning, we help families not only preserve their business and reputational legacy but also maintain their familial bonds,” concludes Janine.